Geoffrey was killed inside the a cycling accident from inside the 1186 and Constance hitched (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, cuatro th Earl of Chester, on step 3 rd February 1188, when you look at the a marriage developed from the King Henry 11. So it relationship deteriorated and Ranulph imprisoned Constance when you look at the 1196. Rebellions were sparked across the Brittany on her and you can Ranulph create their own into the 1198. Back into Brittany, Constance had her relationships annulled and later when you look at the 1198, she got People de- Trips since their ‘second‘ husband.

Constance passed away old 40, (possibly of leprosy, maybe after giving birth in order to twin girls) toward 5 th beautiful Melitopol women September 1201 during the Nantes

The idea you to Constance had an event with John following death of Geoffrey and you may ahead of John’s relationship so you can Isabella of Gloucester when you look at the 1189, and that she are mom so you can Joanna is extremely controversial and you can possess provoked much dialogue within genealogical sectors.

By simply which have sex which have John, let-alone bearing him an infant, Constance could have mainly based a primary-education dating of affinity with all John’s sisters –– in addition to John’s brother Geoffrey

One to feedback off an excellent genealogist states that ‘new record ‘The new Plantagenet Connection‘ provides penned an enthusiastic ahnentafel of Age Plantagenet, wife out of Henry V11, which gives Joanna’s mom’s term given that Constance (perhaps misnamed Clemence?), Duchess out-of Brittany. This is the Constance who had been John’s sis-in-law! Because of the really-understood animosity between John and Constance and her own attempts to push their unique young man Arthur’s interests as much as the latest throne from England is concerned (and we also the know how disastrously you to definitely ended up!), I truly find the recommended dating a little tough to take. New Constance you to history illustrates cannot struck myself due to the fact on the whom John can potentially coerce into the sleep.‘

‘ An idea who would identify Joanna’s mom as Constance does not account fully for an extremely crucial part of canon rules. Who signify specific shade of the count need certainly to certainly came down to you, if it inside it this new request it, the latest deliberations, or perhaps the actual dispensation alone. In so far as i have always been aware, nothing of your form can be acquired.‘

My own advice for just what it’s really worth, is the fact got Constance already been the mother from Joanna she would absolutely provides brought their up inside her household along with her title would be too also known as Constance’s most other youngsters by the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Housemaid out-of Brittany, Matilda/Maud out-of Brittany and you will Arthur).

Agatha was born from the 1168 in Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It’s well known one to she is actually a domme away from John and many family trees render their particular, even though unmarried, as mother out-of Joanna. Very genealogists although not believe that it’s just supposition one to this woman is Joanna’s mother just like the zero proof or records exist to display which.

Although this was not a consanguineous dating but one of affinity, any basic-degree matchmaking could have made relationships anywhere between Constance and you will any of John’s brothers hopeless in the place of an effective dispensation –– and that considering the party’s score would have was required to come from brand new pope himself

You to resource seem to provided was Sir William Dugdale, regarding Baronage from The united kingdomt (1675-6). He says their supply as Dr David Howell’s ‘History of Wales‘ (1584). Powell’s job is an enlarged version off H Lloyd’s translation of ‘Brand new Historie regarding Cambria‘ by 12 th century Saint Caradoc off Llancarfan. Another resource, ‘Magna Carta Barons‘ from the Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 and names Agatha de- Ferrers, child from Robert de Ferrers, 4th Earl from derby, since Joanna’s mother.

Though she can’t be completely overlooked because a candidate getting mommy off Joanna, certainly there is certain shade off their own when you look at the good chronicle or any other historical site, if the she had in fact become the caretaker of partner of brand new Prince out of Northern Wales.